Picking footage by the facts, not the keywords
Search an archive for "Mars spacecraft" and you get hundreds of results. Most of them are the wrong spacecraft. A film about one mission that cuts to another mission's launch looks fine to a casual viewer and wrong to everyone who knows the subject, and those are the people who comment. So our pipeline does not pick footage by keyword. It picks it by the film's facts.
The film's facts come from its research
Before any footage is searched, the script is researched and sourced. That research gives the film a set of facts: its era, its dated events, and the people, places, objects and organisations it names. Those facts are what the film is about. A keyword is only what the film sounds like.
Every picture is judged against them
Each candidate picture is described, and the archive's own record is read with it: the title, the description and the date the archive gives. Then a judge decides where the picture fits, the way an editor would:
- it shows what this line of narration is about
- it fits this chapter, but not this line
- it fits only the film as a whole
- it does not belong in this film
The judge starts with the facts. A picture of a named person, object or event from the film is a real candidate. A picture of a different mission, a different ship or a different trial, of the same kind, is a no, however much it looks the part. Where the archive record and the picture disagree about what something is, the record wins, because the archive knows what it filmed.
The cheap tricks are ruled out
The judge says no to the things that make a documentary feel padded:
- generic shots of the field (a control room, a lab, a crowd) that nothing ties to the film's events
- a press conference or a ceremony that is not one of the film's events
- a dramatisation with actors, when the film is about the real thing
- burned-in text that names a different subject
- a portrait from the wrong century
- watermarks, title cards and blurry frames
When the judge is not sure, it picks the lower level. An editor leaves out a picture they are not sure of.
It works for any format
None of this is tuned for one film. A true crime film has its own people, places and dates, so does a history film or a science film, and the same rules run on all of them. The facts change from film to film. The rules do not.
The result is footage that matches what is being said, from the right event, in the right decade. That is what makes a viewer trust the narration.
Cheers, Carl